Skip to content
The Crave Guide
0

Peanut Butter Shake

172% of your day's sugar. That's more than a day.

almond

Peanut Butter Shake (medium) at Sonic: 840 calories, 19 g protein, 22 g saturated fat (110% of a day), 700 mg sodium (30%) and 86 g sugar, based on a 2,000-calorie day. The Crave Guide gives it a Crave Score of 0/100, #28 of 35 in frozen at Sonic. Best swap: size it to mini, which raises the Crave Score to 34/100 and saves 400 calories, 9 g saturated fat, 370 mg sodium and 43 g sugar. Nutrition as published by Sonic, checked Nov 17, 2026.

Your order

Regular

    Switch on the change to see the lighter version: 49% less of your day.

    SONIC

    ORDER · PEANUT BUTTER SHAKE, MEDIUM

    • Peanut Butter Shake · Medium840 cal

    CALORIES840
    SUGAR86g
    SAT FAT22g
    CHOLESTEROL100mg
    SODIUM700mg
    PROTEIN19g
    ★ CRAVE SCORE0

    1 item · switch on a change for the lighter version

    THANK YOU · COME CRAVE AGAIN

    What makes it high

    Share of your day, and the parts that add it.

    Sugar86 g · 172% of your day
    Sat fat22 g · 110% of your day
    Calories840 cal · 42% of your day

    The chain only publishes this as one total, so we can't split it into parts. The line marks a whole day.

    Nutrition by size

    Calories
    840
    Sugar
    86g
    Protein
    19g
    Sat fat
    22g
    Total fat
    43g
    Trans fat
    0g
    Cholesterol
    100mg
    Sodium
    700mg
    Carbs
    103g
    Fiber
    2g
    Added sugar
    n/p
    Caffeine
    n/p

    n/p = not published by the chain. We leave it blank instead of guessing.

    Every swap, biggest win first

    1. Size it to MiniSmall change+34
      • −400 cal
      • −43 g sugar
      • −9 g sat fat
      • −55 mg cholesterol
    2. Size it to SmallSmall change±0
      • −210 cal
      • −16 g sugar
      • −5 g sat fat
      • −20 mg cholesterol

    Same vibe at other chains

    See every dupe of the Peanut Butter Shake →

    Source: Sonic nutrition info, checked Nov 17, 2026