Skip to content
The Crave Guide
0

Peanut Butter Shake

136% of your day's sugar. That's more than a day.

almond

Peanut Butter Shake at Five Guys: 846 calories, 19 g protein, 21 g saturated fat (105% of a day), 535 mg sodium (23%) and 68 g sugar, based on a 2,000-calorie day. The Crave Guide gives it a Crave Score of 0/100, #10 of 10 in frozen at Five Guys. Five Guys publishes no lighter version of it. Nutrition as published by Five Guys, checked Nov 17, 2026.

Your order

Regular

No swap options available based on the available data. Having it anyway? Go lighter for the rest of the day. “I really crave this!” shows you how.

FIVE GUYS

ORDER · PEANUT BUTTER SHAKE, REGULAR

  • Peanut Butter Shake · Regular846 cal

CALORIES846
SUGAR68g
SAT FAT21g
CHOLESTEROL96mg
SODIUM535mg
PROTEIN19g
★ CRAVE SCORE0

1 item · as it comes

THANK YOU · COME CRAVE AGAIN

What makes it high

Share of your day, and the parts that add it.

Sugar68 g · 136% of your day
Sat fat21 g · 105% of your day
Calories846 cal · 42% of your day

The chain only publishes this as one total, so we can't split it into parts. The line marks a whole day.

Nutrition by size

Calories
846
Sugar
68g
Protein
19g
Sat fat
21g
Total fat
54g
Trans fat
0g
Cholesterol
96mg
Sodium
535mg
Carbs
74g
Fiber
3g
Added sugar
n/p
Caffeine
n/p

n/p = not published by the chain. We leave it blank instead of guessing.

Source: Five Guys nutrition info, checked Nov 17, 2026