Skip to content
The Crave Guide

Filet-O-Fish vs McChicken

Close call: a Crave Score of 79 for the McChicken and 78 for the Filet-O-Fish, out of 100.

In favor of the Filet-O-Fish: 10 fewer calories. Want the Filet-O-Fish anyway? Order it with no cheese for a Crave Score of 82, ahead of the McChicken.

McDonald's

Filet-O-Fish

Regular · 380 cal

78

McDonald's

McChicken

Regular · 390 cal

79

Nutrition side by side

NutrientFilet-O-FishRegularMcChickenRegular
Crave Score7879
Calories38019% of a day39020% of a day
Protein16 g14 g
Saturated fat4 g20% of a day3.5 g18% of a day
Sodium580 mg25% of a day560 mg24% of a day
Sugar4 g4 g
Added sugar4 g4 g
Carbs38 g38 g
Fiber1 g1 g
Cholesterol30 mg40 mg
Trans fat0 g0 g

Sizes as each chain sells them. % of a day is based on 2,000 calories and 2,300 mg sodium. n/p = not published.

Which one for your goal

  • Lightest overall · McChicken7879
  • Watching calories · Filet-O-Fish6261
  • Protein for the calories · Filet-O-Fish5345
  • Watching sugar & carbs · Tie7878
  • Watching sodium · McChicken5051
  • Watching cholesterol · McChicken7475

Make either one lighter

  • Filet-O-Fish

    Order it with no cheese

    Crave Score 78 → 82 · 20 fewer calories · 100 mg less sodium

    See the receipt →
  • McChicken

    Order it with no mayo

    Crave Score 79 → 82 · 100 fewer calories · 60 mg less sodium

    See the receipt →

More matchups

Source: McDonald's nutrition info, checked Nov 16, 2026

General guidance from FDA daily values, not medical advice. How we score