Skip to content
The Crave Guide

Five Guys Cheeseburger vs McDonald's Quarter Pounder with Cheese

Lighter pick: the McDonald's Quarter Pounder with Cheese, with a Crave Score of 17 vs 0 out of 100.

Compared with the Five Guys Cheeseburger: 464 fewer calories and 14 g less saturated fat. In favor of the Five Guys Cheeseburger: 70 mg less sodium, 4 g less sugar and 15 g more protein (45 g vs 30 g). Picking the McDonald's Quarter Pounder with Cheese once a week saves 464 calories a week and 24,128 a year, about 12 days' worth of food.

Five Guys

Cheeseburger

2 patties · 984 cal

0

McDonald's

Quarter Pounder with Cheese

Regular · 520 cal

17

Nutrition side by side

NutrientFive Guys Cheeseburger2 pattiesMcDonald's Quarter Pounder with CheeseRegular
Crave Score017
Calories98449% of a day52026% of a day
Protein45 g30 g
Saturated fat26 g130% of a day12 g60% of a day
Sodium1,070 mg47% of a day1,140 mg50% of a day
Sugar6 g10 g
Added sugarn/p8 g
Carbs37 g42 g
Fiber1 g2 g
Cholesterol165 mg95 mg
Trans fat2 g1.5 g

Sizes as each chain sells them. % of a day is based on 2,000 calories and 2,300 mg sodium. n/p = not published.

Which one for your goal

  • Lightest overall · McDonald's Quarter Pounder with Cheese017
  • Watching calories · McDonald's Quarter Pounder with Cheese248
  • Protein for the calories · McDonald's Quarter Pounder with Cheese5772
  • Watching sugar & carbs · Five Guys Cheeseburger7565
  • Watching sodium · Five Guys Cheeseburger71
  • Watching cholesterol · Tie00

Make either one lighter

  • Five Guys Cheeseburger

    No lighter version published.

  • McDonald's Quarter Pounder with Cheese

    Order it with no ketchup

    Crave Score 17 → 19 · 20 fewer calories · 160 mg less sodium

    See the receipt →

Over a week

Picking the McDonald's Quarter Pounder with Cheese instead of the Five Guys Cheeseburger: once a week saves 464 calories; three times a week, 1,392 calories. Over a year at once a week that's 24,128 calories.

More matchups

Source: Five Guys nutrition info, checked Nov 17, 2026

Source: McDonald's nutrition info, checked Nov 16, 2026

General guidance from FDA daily values, not medical advice. How we score